| Summary: | bus-test failed to complete tests. | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Product: | dbus | Reporter: | Andrew SG Rojek <dev.admin> |
| Component: | core | Assignee: | Havoc Pennington <hp> |
| Status: | RESOLVED FIXED | QA Contact: | John (J5) Palmieri <johnp> |
| Severity: | normal | ||
| Priority: | medium | CC: | dev.admin, walters |
| Version: | 1.2.x | Keywords: | NEEDINFO |
| Hardware: | x86 (IA32) | ||
| OS: | Mac OS X (All) | ||
| Whiteboard: | committed, awaiting testing | ||
| i915 platform: | i915 features: | ||
"Unknown group "root" on element <deny>" This sounds like the configuration file needs to be different for OS X? Is there no group "root" there? Is this still reproducible with 1.2.3? At a higher level I'm trying to get all OS X integration done here: http://bugs.freedesktop.org/show_bug.cgi?id=14259 Thanks for reply. Checked groups for 'root' using dscl and no account has been created for 'root'. As far as I'm aware, root user is grouped with other admin accounts under 'admin'. I'll try v1.2.3 and get back to you soon. A. Colin,
Just got round to testing the latest release of dbus (v.1.2.12) and the
'make check' output is almost identical with the same problems.
After examining the system accounts and several experimentations
with group accounts on the Mac, the group error reported before,
can be eliminated by changing the statements in the test file
'many-rules.conf' on lines 20 and 38 to read,
<deny group="wheel"/>
As an unqualified opinion, the group 'wheel' (System Group) seems to
be the most commonly used group when associated with the 'root'
account on the Mac and is also the only member of that group.
Therefore, it would seem that it would be a suitable substitute.
Alternatively, the group 'sys' (System) also has 'root' as its only
member, but is not widely used throughout the system. Also,
group 'admin' (Administrators) has as its members all the user
accounts that have administrator status. Don't know if that one
is of any help however.
With root group set to wheel, the rest of the tests progressed without
any related errors. For a future addition, could you get configure to
detect darwin OS and reconfigure the conf files to read the group 'wheel' ?
Getting back to the output from the check, the valid and invalid
message tests all seem to produce the same message,
"message builder language no longer supported"
and I'm not aware of the implications of this.
Being able to progress deeper into the tests, the following test failed,
./bus-test: Running message dispatch test
check_get_connection_unix_process_id
this one seemed a bit more serious.
OUTPUT FROM 'MAKE CHECK'
----------------------
Making check in dbus
make check-am
make check-TESTS
Test data in ../test/data
dbus-test: running string tests
dbus-test: checking for memleaks
dbus-test: running sysdeps tests
dbus-test: checking for memleaks
dbus-test: running data-slot tests
dbus-test: checking for memleaks
dbus-test: running misc tests
dbus-test: checking for memleaks
dbus-test: running address tests
dbus-test: checking for memleaks
dbus-test: running server tests
dbus-test: checking for memleaks
dbus-test: running object-tree tests
dbus-test: checking for memleaks
dbus-test: running signature tests
dbus-test: checking for memleaks
dbus-test: running marshalling tests
dbus-test: checking for memleaks
recursive marshal tests disabled
dbus-test: running byteswap tests
120 blocks swapped from order 'l' to 'B'
120 blocks swapped from order 'B' to 'l'
dbus-test: checking for memleaks
dbus-test: running memory tests
dbus-test: checking for memleaks
dbus-test: running mem-pool tests
dbus-test: checking for memleaks
dbus-test: running list tests
dbus-test: checking for memleaks
dbus-test: running marshal-validate tests
dbus-test: checking for memleaks
dbus-test: running marshal-header tests
dbus-test: checking for memleaks
dbus-test: running message tests
testing message loading: trivial example of each message type 4 test loads cumulative
testing message loading: assorted arguments 124 test loads cumulative
testing message loading: assorted special cases 144 test loads cumulative
testing message loading: each uint32 modified 35366 test loads cumulative
testing message loading: wrong body lengths 38366 test loads cumulative
testing message loading: each byte modified 51545 test loads cumulative
51545 sample messages tested
validity 0 seen 378 times
validity 1 seen 3477 times
validity 2 seen 177 times
validity 4 seen 3 times
validity 5 seen 3 times
validity 6 seen 3 times
validity 7 seen 273 times
validity 8 seen 3 times
validity 9 seen 15780 times
validity 10 seen 173 times
validity 11 seen 2740 times
validity 12 seen 6078 times
validity 13 seen 3960 times
validity 14 seen 360 times
validity 15 seen 3 times
validity 16 seen 1080 times
validity 17 seen 1440 times
validity 18 seen 1107 times
validity 19 seen 3 times
validity 20 seen 1080 times
validity 21 seen 6480 times
validity 22 seen 3 times
validity 23 seen 3 times
validity 24 seen 720 times
validity 25 seen 360 times
validity 26 seen 1440 times
validity 27 seen 720 times
validity 28 seen 360 times
validity 29 seen 3 times
validity 30 seen 720 times
validity 31 seen 3 times
validity 32 seen 360 times
validity 33 seen 3 times
validity 34 seen 3 times
validity 35 seen 14625 times
validity 37 seen 6666 times
validity 38 seen 2013 times
validity 39 seen 15447 times
validity 40 seen 1788 times
validity 41 seen 8325 times
validity 42 seen 3408 times
validity 43 seen 4875 times
validity 45 seen 3327 times
validity 46 seen 7485 times
validity 47 seen 1125 times
validity 48 seen 3 times
validity 49 seen 3 times
validity 50 seen 144 times
validity 51 seen 3 times
validity 54 seen 12 times
validity -4 seen 0 times
validity -2 seen 0 times
validity 3 seen 0 times
validity 36 seen 0 times
validity 44 seen 0 times
validity 52 seen 0 times
validity 53 seen 0 times
validity 55 seen 0 times
Testing valid-messages:
Could not load array-of-array-of-uint32.message, message builder language no longer supported
Could not load dict-simple.message, message builder language no longer supported
Could not load dict.message, message builder language no longer supported
Could not load emptiness.message, message builder language no longer supported
Could not load lots-of-arguments.message, message builder language no longer supported
Could not load no-padding.message, message builder language no longer supported
Could not load opposite-endian.message, message builder language no longer supported
Could not load recursive-types.message, message builder language no longer supported
Could not load simplest-manual.message, message builder language no longer supported
Could not load simplest.message, message builder language no longer supported
Could not load standard-acquire-service.message, message builder language no longer supported
Could not load standard-hello.message, message builder language no longer supported
Could not load standard-list-services.message, message builder language no longer supported
Could not load standard-service-exists.message, message builder language no longer supported
Could not load unknown-header-field.message, message builder language no longer supported
Testing invalid-messages:
Could not load array-of-nil.message, message builder language no longer supported
Could not load array-with-mixed-types.message, message builder language no longer supported
Could not load bad-boolean-array.message, message builder language no longer supported
Could not load bad-boolean.message, message builder language no longer supported
Could not load bad-endian.message, message builder language no longer supported
Could not load bad-header-field-alignment.message, message builder language no longer supported
boolean-has-no-value.message-raw
Could not load local-namespace.message, message builder language no longer supported
Could not load no-dot-in-name.message, message builder language no longer supported
Could not load not-nul-header-padding.message, message builder language no longer supported
Could not load overlong-name.message, message builder language no longer supported
Could not load too-little-header-padding.message, message builder language no longer supported
Could not load too-much-header-padding-by-far.message, message builder language no longer supported
Could not load too-much-header-padding.message, message builder language no longer supported
Could not load too-short-dict.message, message builder language no longer supported
Testing incomplete-messages:
Could not load missing-body.message, message builder language no longer supported
dbus-test: checking for memleaks
dbus-test: running hash tests
Computing test hash keys...
... done.
dbus-test: checking for memleaks
dbus-test: running spawn tests
dbus-test: checking for memleaks
dbus-test: running credentials tests
dbus-test: checking for memleaks
dbus-test: running userdb tests
Current user: root homedir: /var/root gids: 0 1 2 8 29 3 9 4 503 5 80 20
dbus-test: checking for memleaks
dbus-test: running keyring tests
1 keys in test
dbus-test: checking for memleaks
dbus-test: running sha tests
SHA-1: H>SHS Type 1 Strings<H
SHA-1: H>SHS Type 2 Strings<H
SHA-1: H>SHS Type 3 Strings<H
(ending tests due to Type 3 tests seen - this is normal)
Passed the 229 SHA-1 tests in the test file
dbus-test: checking for memleaks
dbus-test: running auth tests
Testing auth:
anonymous-client-successful.auth-script
anonymous-server-successful.auth-script
cancel.auth-script
client-out-of-mechanisms.auth-script
external-failed.auth-script
external-root.auth-script
external-silly.auth-script
external-successful.auth-script
extra-bytes.auth-script
fail-after-n-attempts.auth-script
fallback.auth-script
invalid-command-client.auth-script
invalid-command.auth-script
invalid-hex-encoding.auth-script
mechanisms.auth-script
dbus-test: checking for memleaks
dbus-test: running pending-call tests
dbus-test: checking for memleaks
dbus-test: completed successfully
PASS: dbus-test
==================
All 1 tests passed
==================
Making check in bus
make check-TESTS
./bus-test: Running expire list test
./bus-test: checking for memleaks
./bus-test: Running config file parser test
Testing retrieving the default session service directories
default service dir: /Volumes/gnu/gde/org.gnome/share/dbus-1/services
default service dir: /usr/local/share/dbus-1/services
default service dir: /Volumes/gnu/gde/org.gnome/share/dbus-1/services
test service dir: /testusr/testlocal/testshare/dbus-1/services
test service dir: /testusr/testshare/dbus-1/services
test service dir: /usr/local/share/dbus-1/services
test service dir: /testhome/foo/.testlocal/testshare/dbus-1/services
Testing retrieving the default system service directories
default service dir: /testusr/testlocal/testshare/dbus-1/system-services
default service dir: /testusr/testshare/dbus-1/system-services
default service dir: /usr/local/share/dbus-1/system-services
test service dir: /testusr/testlocal/testshare/dbus-1/system-services
test service dir: /testusr/testshare/dbus-1/system-services
test service dir: /usr/local/share/dbus-1/system-services
Testing valid files:
basic.conf
debug-allow-all-sha1.conf
debug-allow-all.conf
entities.conf
many-rules.conf
session.conf
system.conf
Testing invalid files:
badselinux-1.conf
badselinux-2.conf
circular-1.conf
circular-2.conf
circular-3.conf
not-well-formed.conf
truncated-file.conf
Comparing equivalent files:
basic-1.conf
basic-2.conf
Comparing equivalent files:
entities-1.conf
entities-2.conf
./bus-test: checking for memleaks
./bus-test: Running policy test
./bus-test: checking for memleaks
./bus-test: Running signals test
./bus-test: checking for memleaks
./bus-test: Running SHA1 connection test
./bus-test: checking for memleaks
./bus-test: Running message dispatch test
check_get_connection_unix_process_id:1278 received message interface "(unset)" member "(unset)" error name "org.freedesktop.DBus.Error.UnixProcessIdUnknown" on 0x205210, expecting not this error
0 bus-test 0x0007a748 _dbus_print_backtrace + 40
1 bus-test 0x00075762 _dbus_abort + 18
2 bus-test 0x000622e6 _dbus_warn + 102
3 bus-test 0x00013076 bus_dispatch_remove_connection + 454
4 bus-test 0x00018442 bus_dispatch_remove_connection + 21906
5 bus-test 0x000184e7 bus_dispatch_test + 39
6 bus-test 0x00025ba2 main + 338
7 bus-test 0x00001846 start + 54
Process 92900 sleeping for gdb attach
/bin/sh: line 1: 92900 Abort trap DBUS_TEST_DATA=../test/data DBUS_TEST_HOMEDIR=../dbus DBUS_FATAL_WARNINGS=1 DBUS_BLOCK_ON_ABORT=1 ${dir}$tst
FAIL: bus-test
./bus-test-system: Running config file parser (trivial) test
Testing valid files:
basic.conf
debug-allow-all-sha1.conf
debug-allow-all.conf
entities.conf
many-rules.conf
session.conf
system.conf
Testing invalid file:
../test/data/invalid-config-files/not-well-formed.conf
Testing valid file:
../test/data/valid-config-files/system.conf
Testing values from: ../test/data/valid-config-files/system.conf
<type>system</type> OKAY!
<standard_system_service_dirs/> OKAY!
./bus-test-system: checking for memleaks
./bus-test-system: Success
PASS: bus-test-system
./bus-test-launch-helper: Running launch helper OOM checks
./bus-test-launch-helper: checking for memleaks
./bus-test-launch-helper: Success
PASS: bus-test-launch-helper
===================
1 of 3 tests failed
===================
make[2]: *** [check-TESTS] Error 1
make[1]: *** [check-am] Error 2
make: *** [check-recursive] Error 1
Hi, I would prefer to see these kinds of things consolidated in the general Mac patch in bug 14259. Any changes to configure.in etc are likely to overlap. Just noticed I already said that, sorry. Anyways I know the other Mac patch needs review...getting closer. I think this should be fixed now, can you confirm? Will get round to testing soon. A. This is believed to have been fixed ages ago. Please reopen and provide more information if it turns out not to work. |
Use of freedesktop.org services, including Bugzilla, is subject to our Code of Conduct. How we collect and use information is described in our Privacy Policy.
SUMMARY -------- Whilst running the tests for dbus [v1.2.1], the bus-test application 'quits unexpectedly'. OVERVIEW -------- Configuration and make executed without reporting any errors. STEPS TO REPRODUCE. ------------------ configure make make check As this seems to be testing the libexpat library, I tried to build it with libxml instead of expat with the --with-xml option. Output from tests is below. The tests terminate before any crash logs are generated. ACTUAL RESULTS. -------------- Output from 'make check' -------------------- ... Unknown group "root" on element <deny> 0 bus-test 0x00079048 _dbus_print_backtrace + 40 1 bus-test 0x00074192 _dbus_abort + 18 2 bus-test 0x00060dc6 _dbus_warn + 102 3 bus-test 0x00008f58 bus_config_parser_check_doctype + 5720 4 bus-test 0x0000945b bus_config_parser_start_element + 971 5 bus-test 0x000242c6 bus_connection_dispatch_all_messages + 598 6 libexpat.1.dylib 0x000e311a XML_SetEncoding + 6324 7 libexpat.1.dylib 0x000e39ba XML_SetEncoding + 8532 8 libexpat.1.dylib 0x000e4221 XML_SetEncoding + 10683 9 libexpat.1.dylib 0x000e56ac XML_SetEncoding + 15942 10 libexpat.1.dylib 0x000de5ff XML_ParseBuffer + 139 11 bus-test 0x000247ac bus_config_load + 908 12 bus-test 0x0000b8a5 bus_config_parser_steal_service_context_table + 725 13 bus-test 0x0000c26f bus_config_parser_test + 1615 14 bus-test 0x00024aca main + 154 15 bus-test 0x00001cd6 start + 54 Process 81858 sleeping for gdb attach /bin/sh: line 1: 81858 Abort trap DBUS_TEST_DATA=../test/data DBUS_TEST_HOMEDIR=../dbus DBUS_FATAL_WARNINGS=1 DBUS_BLOCK_ON_ABORT=1 ${dir}$tst FAIL: bus-test ... Output from OSX Reporting Application. ------------------------------- Thread 0 Crashed: 0 libSystem.B.dylib 0x9241db9e __kill + 10 1 libSystem.B.dylib 0x92494ec2 raise + 26 2 libSystem.B.dylib 0x924a447f abort + 73 3 bus-test 0x000741e4 _dbus_abort + 100 4 bus-test 0x00060dc6 _dbus_warn + 102 5 bus-test 0x00008f58 append_rule_from_element + 4552 (config-parser.c:1495) 6 bus-test 0x0000945b bus_config_parser_start_element + 971 (config-parser.c:1598) 7 bus-test 0x000242c6 expat_StartElementHandler + 406 (config-loader-expat.c:111) 8 libexpat.1.dylib 0x000e311a XML_SetEncoding + 6324 9 libexpat.1.dylib 0x000e39ba XML_SetEncoding + 8532 10 libexpat.1.dylib 0x000e4221 XML_SetEncoding + 10683 11 libexpat.1.dylib 0x000e56ac XML_SetEncoding + 15942 12 libexpat.1.dylib 0x000de5ff XML_ParseBuffer + 139 13 bus-test 0x000247ac bus_config_load + 908 (config-loader-expat.c:245) 14 bus-test 0x0000b8a5 process_test_valid_subdir + 629 (config-parser.c:2626) 15 bus-test 0x0000c26f bus_config_parser_test + 1615 (config-parser.c:3393) 16 bus-test 0x00024aca main + 154 (test-main.c:107) 17 bus-test 0x00001cd6 start + 54 Thread 0 crashed with X86 Thread State (32-bit): eax: 0x00000000 ebx: 0x924a443f ecx: 0xbfffde3c edx: 0x9241db9e edi: 0x00000000 esi: 0xa0222578 ebp: 0xbfffde58 esp: 0xbfffde3c ss: 0x0000001f efl: 0x00000282 eip: 0x9241db9e cs: 0x00000007 ds: 0x0000001f es: 0x0000001f fs: 0x00000000 gs: 0x00000037 cr2: 0x2ee77000 Binary Images: 0x1000 - 0x9dfeb +bus-test ??? (???) <aeab617962e29aedf5a76777de0c7957> /Volumes/src/src_gnm_base/dbus-1.2.1/bus/bus-test 0xdd000 - 0xfbfe3 libexpat.1.dylib ??? (???) <eff8a63a23a7d07af62b36fdb329e393> /usr/lib/libexpat.1.dylib 0x8fe00000 - 0x8fe2da53 dyld 96.2 (???) <06900973e83f70548b7a2a5fa6435865> /usr/lib/dyld 0x923ae000 - 0x9250eff3 libSystem.B.dylib ??? (???) <a12f397abf2285077b89bd726bff5b18> /usr/lib/libSystem.B.dylib 0x96112000 - 0x96116fff libmathCommon.A.dylib ??? (???) /usr/lib/system/libmathCommon.A.dylib 0x96a96000 - 0x96a9dfe9 libgcc_s.1.dylib ??? (???) <f53c808e87d1184c0f9df63aef53ce0b> /usr/lib/libgcc_s.1.dylib 0xffff0000 - 0xffff1780 libSystem.B.dylib ??? (???) /usr/lib/libSystem.B.dylib Output from 'make check' with --with-xml=libxml. ---------------------------------------- ... dbus-test: running spawn tests Not expecting error when launching segfaulting executable: org.freedesktop.DBus.Error.Spawn.ExecFailed: Failed to execute program .../dbus-1.2.1/test/test-segfault: Unknown error: 0 Unit test failed: spawn FAIL: dbus-test ... EXPECTED RESULTS. --------------- pass tests. BUILD AND PLATFORM. ------------------ date: 13 July 2008 platform: Mac OSX 10.5.4/Darwin 9.4.0 ADDITIONAL BUILDS AND PLATFORMS. ------------------------------ unknown. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION. ---------------------- libexpat is installed in two locations, using factory installed library. packages installed prior to dbus follow the gnome recommended order for a full install. all libraries installed are with the option --disable-static.